Deal Hudson
Here is a clarification of what happened at St. Thomas Aquinas Parish regarding Cong. Brian Higgins. Evidently Cong. Higgins, NOT Deacon McConnell, walked out of Mass. Sorry about the confusion. Below is a letter from a Catholic pro-life activist on the subject. I share his reservations about naming individuals from the pulpit -- that's a homiletic habit that could get way out of hand. There would have been an artful way to do it, without naming anyone. In fact, if the Bishop had written something in the diocesan newspaper about the importance of rejecting federal funding on embryonic stem cell research then nothing would have needed to be said.
So, yes, the Deacon went overboard. BUT, the incident underlines a growing frustration in the Church toward the hand-holding of Catholic legislators who show disdain for innocent life.
Years ago in 1963, Cardinal Bernadin in his now famous "Seamless Garment" speech stated that pro-lifers must become "visibly" involved in the movement for social justice, or he would not consider them truly pro-life.
Ok, but what if bishops and priests are not "visibly" pro-life about, say, abortion and protecting human embryos from being torn apart for research. That's the source of frustration that leads to moments of rudeness such as that of the good deacon in Buffalo.
Dear Fellow Catholic:
"BUFFALO, January 25, 2007 (LifeSiteNews.com) – A Catholic deacon has been reprimanded for taking a pro-abortion Congressman to task on his voting record during a homily on “Respect Life Sunday.”
Deacon Tom McDonnell pointed out that Democrat Rep. Brian Higgins, in attendance with his family, had voted in favour of legislation allowing federal funding for embryonic stem cell research and suggested that parishioners should talk to him about his vote. The Congressman and his family walked out of the church."
Here is the full text of the article:
http://www.lifesite.net/ldn/printerfriendly.html
I do not have an extensive email list of Catholics so please forward this to all Catholics you know, as well as anybody you think should see it.
My thought on this homily is that normally the homilist should not mention any sinner by name. I am not sure what the rubrics of the Mass would say on the subject, but he may deserve a reprimand for that.
However, things are not normal when a sinner is not only publicly open in his contempt f or essential Church teachings, those on which all Catholics must agree in full in order to preserve their communion with the Church, but also enacts laws which over-turn Church teachings.
The pastor of St. Thomas Aquinas, Rev. Art Smith, and Buffalo, Edward U. Kmiec couldn't wait to apologize to Democrat Rep. Brian Higgins for the deacon's telling the pew warmers that Higgins voted against Church teachings. We are told that Higgins and his family walked out of the church. Good.
If the the Diocese of Buffalo had a real man for a bishop he would have publicly excommunicated Higgins a long time ago for promoting abortion and embryonic stem cell research. Whose side is he on?
As president I am considering giving a Thomas More Award to the deacon for standing up for the truth at the expense of a whole lot of grief, quite possibly his removal as deacon. I will await more news. I would also appreciate your comments.
The only such award Thomas More Institute has given so far was to Judge Roy Moore, late of the Alabama Supreme Court who publicly stood up for the Ten Commandments at the expense of his career. I'd really like to give it to a Catholic this time.
Please let me know what you think. Please expand this list.
Michael H. Smith
President
Thomas More Institute (dot org)
P. O. Box 709
Stanardsville, Virginia 22973
434-960-5151